Insurers Should Pay Arbitration Awards Within 30 Days
NAMD supports payment of independent dispute resolution awards within 30 days, as the No Surprises Act already requires.
Providers win the large majority of these disputes, about 85% of federal payment disputes in 2025, but winning does not guarantee payment. The Fifth Circuit in 2025 and the Second Circuit in September 2026 both ruled that providers cannot sue to enforce an unpaid award. Enforcement is left to federal agencies, and the Supreme Court declined to review the question in January 2026. A bipartisan bill, the No Surprises Act Enforcement Act, would add penalties and interest for plans that miss the 30-day deadline.
The other side: insurers argue that awards run far above benchmark rates and drive up premiums, and that Congress chose administrative enforcement over private lawsuits.
See all of NAMD's policy positions and the series Where the Money Goes.
Sources
- Arnall Golden Gregory: Second Circuit joins Fifth Circuit on no private right of action to collect IDR awards
- Becker's Payer: Who enforces No Surprises Act payouts?
- HFMA: IDR enforcement uncertain after Supreme Court declines review
Join/Renew Now






