The Case for Paying Physicians What They're Worth
Physicians keep the health system running, and the money flowing through that system has grown far faster than what reaches the people providing the care. This is NAMD's case for higher physician pay: the numbers, the obstacles and what physicians can do.
The cost is smaller than you think
Medicare's physician fee schedule paid for $93.8 billion of services in 2024. A 20% increase would cost about $19 billion a year, of which Medicare would pay roughly $15 billion. That is about 2% of the $839.2 billion Congress appropriated for the Department of Defense for fiscal 2026, or about eight days of Pentagon spending.
The Congressional Budget Office estimates that the 2025 tax and spending law will add $3.4 trillion to deficits from 2025 through 2034. That is roughly 18 times the ten-year cost of a 20% Medicare raise. These are different policies with different goals, and reasonable people differ on both. The point is scale: raising Medicare physician pay by a fifth is a small line in a federal budget where national defense alone tops $1 trillion.
Across all payers, a 20% increase would cost about $222 billion a year. That is an upper bound, since U.S. spending on physician and clinical services was $1.11 trillion in 2024, and the category includes other clinicians and practice overhead. Most of it would be paid by insurers and employers, not the Treasury.
Medicare has fallen behind
Adjusted for practice cost inflation, Medicare physician payment has fallen 33% since 2001. Physicians are the only Medicare provider type without an annual update tied to inflation. The proposed 2027 rule would cut the conversion factor again, to $32.84 for most physicians.
Doctors, hospitals and insurers
Hospital care took $1.6 trillion of U.S. health spending in 2024 and physician and clinical services $1.1 trillion. Hospital prices rose 3.4%, the fastest since 2007, while physician and clinical service prices rose 1.8%. Hospitals now employ 59.7% of physicians and set the terms of those jobs. Hospitals say their margins are thin, with a median operating margin of about 1.3% in 2025, but a vacancy costs a hospital months of lost revenue and recruiting expense, and an offer that undercuts the market costs more than it saves. Physicians should negotiate with their own production data and benchmarks in hand.
Insurers are the other side of the table. Under the No Surprises Act, providers have won about 85% of federal payment disputes, but two appeals courts have ruled that they cannot sue to enforce unpaid awards. NAMD supports payment within 30 days and opposes replacing arbitration with a fixed benchmark.
Own the facility
Physicians can own ambulatory surgery centers with almost no restriction under Medicare, and a surgery center is the most practical first step toward ownership. The next step, a physician-owned hospital, is currently blocked by the Affordable Care Act. Bills in Congress would repeal or narrow that ban, and NAMD supports them. Before building anything, check your state's certificate-of-need rules and hire a healthcare attorney, because self-referral and anti-kickback laws are strict.
The other side
Raising physician pay has real opponents. The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission finds that beneficiaries have relatively good access and recommends only a modest 2027 update. Higher Medicare rates raise federal spending and patients' 20% coinsurance. Insurers argue arbitration awards run far above benchmark rates, and hospital groups say physician-owned facilities draw profitable patients from community hospitals. The physician response is that access depends on practices staying viable, that costs have outrun payment for two decades, and that competition lowers prices.
Read the full series
- Why Physician Pay Is Under Pressure
- What a Physician's Time Is Really Worth
- Where the Money Goes
- Taxes: Keep More of What You Earn
- How to Raise Physician Pay
- Know Your Contract
- Is Your Non-Compete Legal?
- Practices for Sale
NAMD, with more than 180,000 physician members, advocates for fair pay and gives physicians the information they need to protect their income. Join NAMD today.
Sources: CMS National Health Expenditures 2024; MedPAC; Congressional Research Service and Congressional Budget Office; AMA; Kaufman Hall National Hospital Flash Report; CMS arbitration data as reported by Becker's; Physicians Advocacy Institute. Dollar comparisons are approximate and for scale only. This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.
Join/Renew Now






