The Covid-19 Tipping Point Doctors Fear Most Is Getting Closer


 
12.3k
Shares
 

By Julia Belluz

When Theodore Iwashyna cared for his first Covid-19 patient in March, he felt a wave of terror wash over him. “I was convinced I was going to either die or get my family sick,” the pulmonologist and professor of critical care medicine at the University of Michigan recalls.

Little was known about the novel coronavirus then, and Iwashyna couldn’t stop thinking back to the last pandemic coronavirus, SARS, when more than half of all deaths in a nearby hotspot, Toronto, were hospital-acquired infections.

Nowadays, Iwashyna is less worried about himself, his family, or even his very ill patients. “I don’t expect my Covid patients to die,” he says, “I expect most of them to get through.”

By several measures, the coronavirus mortality rate has fallen over the course of the pandemic — even for those at the highest risk of death. People who are diagnosed today appear to have better odds of surviving the disease compared to the first wave of patients.

“It’s a silver lining in a hard time,” said Bilal Mateen, a clinical-academic at Kings College Hospital and an author on a new study focused on mortality in UK critical care units, “but it’s by no means an excuse to take your foot off the pedal.”

That’s because even with the advances in Covid-19 treatment, there’s still a tipping point at which the mortality rate could spike — when there are far more patients than hospital beds, staff, and ventilators. “If hospitals get overwhelmed, obviously it’s difficult to provide optimal care,” said Tom Frieden, the CEO of the health nonprofit Resolve to Save Lives.

And hospitals are becoming overwhelmed again, on both sides of the Atlantic.

France is reporting the highest number of Covid-19 hospitalizations since April — with more than half of all ICU beds full in the country. The Czech Republic — home to the fastest-growing epidemic in Europe — had to mobilize the army to build a Covid-19 field hospital and call its foreign health workers home to help with the emergency. In Belgium, even doctors diagnosed with the disease have been asked to continue working while non-urgent surgeries have been called off.

The stateside outlook is equally grim. Covid-19 hospitalizations have increased by 46 percent from a month ago, surpassing 44,000 on October 27. As Dylan Scott reports, this has forced radical measures across the country: Wisconsin and Texas are building field hospitals, while Idaho is planning to transfer patients out of state, and Utah is ready to ration care.

Covid-19 deaths by day have also recently risen somewhat in the US, although not yet to the height of earlier waves of the pandemic.

We may be approaching the moment at which progress saving lives can’t be sustained. “Each hospital’s overwhelmed point is different now than it was in April but there is a point that’s too much for any hospital,” Iwashyna says. “There are only so many hands. You can only be in so many rooms.” Here’s what we know about the falling Covid-19 mortality rate — and why it might start rising again soon.

From spring to summer, the Covid-19 death rate dropped in Europe and the US

It’s been seven months since the World Health Organization (WHO) declared the coronavirus a pandemic, and in that period, the mortality rate among people with Covid-19 improved in countries around the world.

At first, it wasn’t clear whether this trend could be explained mostly by shifting demographics of the disease (people getting sick tended to be younger and healthier over time), more testing, or changes in medical treatments. Researchers have been trying to unpack the data — and they’ve found, even after controlling for differences in patient populations, that mortality improvements appear to hold. Just take a look at these recent papers:

-In this study, recently published, researchers (including Mateen) in England looked at the 30-day mortality rate for 21,000 severely sick Covid-19 patients who were admitted to critical care units across England between March and June 2020. They found the odds of survival improved across the country — and the trend held even after adjusting for a patient’s underlying risks (such as age or other illnesses). In late March, 72 percent of patients who had been admitted to the HDU — a type of critical care ward where patients can be looked after more intensively — were still alive at 30 days. By the end of June, that number climbed to 93 percent. For ICU patients, the number also shot up from 58 percent to 80 percent over that period.


 
12.3k
Shares
 

Articles in this issue:

Journal of Medicine Sign Up

Get the Journal of Medicine delivered to your inbox.

Thank you for subscribing.

No membership required*

Masthead

    • Editor-in Chief:
    • Theodore Massey
    • Editor:
    • Robert Sokonow
    • Editorial Staff:
    • Musaba Dekau
      Lin Takahashi
      Thomas Levine
      Cynthia Casteneda Avina
      Ronald Harvinger
      Lisa Andonis

Leave a Comment

Please keep in mind that all comments are moderated. Please do not use a spam keyword or a domain as your name, or else it will be deleted. Let's have a personal and meaningful conversation instead. Thanks for your comments!

*This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.